When a buyer fails to pay an eligible micro or small enterprise for goods supplied or services rendered, the supplier may approach the Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council (MSEFC) for resolution of the payment dispute. Two important stages of this process are conciliation and arbitration. Understanding how they work can help a business prepare its claim and plan its recovery strategy.
What Is the Difference Between Conciliation and Arbitration Under the MSMED Act?
Conciliation is a settlement-focused process in which the parties try to resolve an MSME payment dispute amicably with the assistance of a conciliator. Arbitration is an adjudicatory process in which the dispute is decided by an arbitrator and may result in a binding award. Under Section 18, if MSEFC conciliation fails and is terminated without settlement, the dispute proceeds to arbitration. IndiaCode+1
Both stages form part of the statutory dispute-resolution framework under the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development (MSMED) Act, 2006.
For a supplier with unpaid invoices, the distinction matters. Conciliation offers an opportunity to settle the dispute. Arbitration provides a formal process for deciding the parties’ claims and objections.
1. What Is MSME Conciliation?
MSME conciliation is a structured process in which the supplier and buyer attempt to resolve a delayed-payment dispute through discussion and settlement, with assistance from a conciliator.
Section 18(2) of the MSMED Act requires the MSEFC to either conduct conciliation itself or seek assistance from an institution or centre providing alternative dispute-resolution services.
The conciliation provisions in Sections 65 to 81 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 apply to this process, as specified in Section 18(2). IndiaCode+1
What is the purpose of conciliation?
The main purpose is to help the parties reach a mutually acceptable settlement without requiring a full arbitral decision.
During conciliation, the parties may discuss:
- The outstanding invoice amount.
- The buyer’s payment obligations.
- Disputed invoices or delivery records.
- Part-payments and financial adjustments.
- Applicable delayed-payment interest.
- A proposed payment schedule.
- Possible settlement terms.
Is conciliation compulsory under Section 18?
Yes. The statutory MSEFC process under Section 18 follows conciliation before arbitration.
However, the Ministry’s Online Dispute Resolution (ODR) Scheme also provides for a separate voluntary pre-MSEFC stage. Parties may use its Digital Guided Pathway or Unmanned Negotiation processes, or opt out of that voluntary stage.
This pre-MSEFC process should not be confused with the statutory conciliation stage under Section 18(2). MSME ODR+1
2. What Is MSME Arbitration?
MSME arbitration is the formal dispute-resolution stage that follows unsuccessful statutory conciliation under Section 18.
If conciliation fails and is terminated without a settlement, Section 18(3) requires the MSEFC to either:
- Take up the dispute for arbitration itself; or
- Refer the dispute to an institution or centre providing alternative dispute-resolution services.
The Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 then applies to the arbitration as provided by Section 18(3). IndiaCode+1
What happens during arbitration?
Unlike conciliation, arbitration involves the formal determination of the dispute.
The supplier and buyer may be required to submit:
- A statement of claim.
- A statement of defence.
- Purchase orders and agreements.
- Tax invoices.
- Delivery and acceptance records.
- Payment statements.
- Correspondence and acknowledgements.
- Interest calculations.
- Other relevant evidence.
The arbitrator considers the parties’ submissions and evidence before deciding the issues.
Can the arbitrator order the buyer to pay?
If the supplier establishes its claim, the arbitral process may result in an award directing payment of the amount found due, along with applicable interest and other relief permitted by law.
The outcome depends on the evidence, legal issues and findings in the particular matter.
[Insert Data/Case Study Placeholder: Add an anonymised example of an MSME payment dispute that proceeded from failed conciliation to arbitration, including the claim amount, disputed issues and outcome.]
3. What Is the Difference Between Conciliation and Arbitration in an MSME Payment Dispute?
The two processes serve different purposes.
| Basis | Conciliation | Arbitration |
|---|---|---|
| Main objective | Help parties reach a settlement | Decide the dispute |
| Nature | Settlement-focused | Adjudicatory |
| Neutral participant | Conciliator | Arbitrator |
| Role of the neutral | Facilitates communication and settlement | Evaluates claims, defences and evidence |
| Outcome | Settlement if parties agree | Arbitral award |
| Is a decision imposed? | No settlement is imposed on unwilling parties | Arbitrator determines the dispute |
| If unsuccessful | Conciliation is terminated without settlement | Award concludes the arbitral determination, subject to applicable legal remedies |
| Legal framework | Section 18(2) MSMED Act and applicable conciliation provisions | Section 18(3) MSMED Act and Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 |
In simple terms: Conciliation attempts to resolve the disagreement. Arbitration decides it.
4. How Does the MSEFC Conciliation Process Work?
An eligible micro or small enterprise may submit a delayed-payment reference through the applicable online filing mechanism.
The Ministry’s MSME Samadhaan facility allows eligible enterprises to submit delayed-payment applications, which are forwarded to the concerned MSEFC for action. The Ministry does not itself decide each individual dispute; the concerned Council handles the reference. MSME RAMP PORTAL+1
The broad statutory process can be understood through these stages:
MSEFC conciliation process
- Delayed-payment applicationThe eligible supplier submits the claim with details of the buyer, invoices and outstanding amount.
- Reference reaches the MSEFCThe concerned Council processes the reference under the applicable framework.
- Buyer is brought into the proceedingsThe buyer receives communication and an opportunity to respond.
- Conciliation beginsThe Council or an appointed institution facilitates settlement discussions.
- Settlement or terminationThe parties may settle, or the conciliation may be terminated without settlement.
- Arbitration if settlement failsThe dispute proceeds under Section 18(3).
The actual notices, hearing arrangements and document requirements depend on the Council’s directions and applicable procedural rules.
5. What Happens During an MSME Conciliation Hearing?
A conciliation hearing gives the parties an opportunity to explain their positions and explore settlement.
The supplier may explain:
- Which invoices remain unpaid.
- When goods were delivered or services were completed.
- What payment terms were agreed.
- What amount has already been received.
- What principal amount remains outstanding.
- How the delayed-payment interest has been calculated.
The buyer may respond by:
- Accepting the outstanding amount.
- Disputing particular invoices.
- Raising quality or delivery objections.
- Producing evidence of payments.
- Proposing instalments or a settlement.
- Disputing the supplier’s statutory eligibility.
Does the supplier need documents for conciliation?
Yes. Even though conciliation focuses on settlement, proper documentation makes the discussion more productive.
We recommend preparing:
- Udyam Registration Certificate.
- Purchase orders and work orders.
- Tax invoices.
- Delivery challans.
- Goods receipt notes.
- Service completion certificates.
- Customer acknowledgements.
- Email and written payment reminders.
- Ledger statements.
- Bank statements.
- Debit and credit notes.
- Invoice-wise interest calculations.
[Insert Data/Case Study Placeholder: Add a sample document checklist or an anonymised example showing how invoice reconciliation helped clarify the amount in dispute.]
6. What Happens If MSME Conciliation Fails?
If the parties cannot reach a settlement, the conciliator or Council must formally terminate the conciliation without settlement.
This is the point at which Section 18(3) becomes relevant.
The MSEFC must then either take up the dispute for arbitration or refer it to an appropriate alternative dispute-resolution institution or centre.
The statutory sequence matters: arbitration under Section 18(3) follows unsuccessful and terminated conciliation under Section 18(2). IndiaCode+1
Can the MSEFC directly skip conciliation and pass an award?
The statutory framework requires the conciliation stage before arbitration.
The Madras High Court has emphasised that the Council must follow the Section 18 sequence and that an award passed without the required conciliation process being recorded may be legally vulnerable. IndiaCode
This is why suppliers and buyers should maintain records of conciliation notices, proceedings and termination.
7. What Happens During MSME Arbitration Proceedings?
Once the matter moves to arbitration, the dispute enters a formal adjudicatory process.
The exact procedure depends on the applicable arbitration framework and directions of the Council or arbitral institution.
The main stages may include:
Stage 1: Statement of claim
The supplier sets out the facts, amount claimed, legal basis and supporting documents.
Stage 2: Statement of defence
The buyer responds to the claim and identifies the issues it disputes.
Stage 3: Evidence and documents
The parties submit relevant agreements, invoices, delivery records, payment statements and correspondence.
Stage 4: Hearings and submissions
The arbitrator may conduct hearings, seek clarifications or direct further submissions.
Stage 5: Determination
The arbitrator evaluates the claims, defences and evidence.
Stage 6: Arbitral award
The arbitrator issues an award deciding the dispute and granting such relief as is legally justified.
What if the buyer does not participate?
The buyer’s absence does not automatically establish the supplier’s entire claim.
The arbitral tribunal must follow the applicable provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, including the rules governing non-participation and evidence. The supplier should still establish its case through relevant documents.
8. How Is the MSME Claim Amount and Interest Calculated?
The supplier should calculate the principal amount and statutory interest carefully.
Three provisions of the MSMED Act are particularly relevant:
| Section | Legal provision | Relevance |
|---|---|---|
| Section 15 | Buyer’s liability to make payment | Establishes the applicable payment deadline |
| Section 16 | Interest on delayed payment | Provides compound interest with monthly rests at three times the RBI-notified bank rate |
| Section 17 | Recovery of amount due | Makes the buyer liable for the principal and applicable interest |
For the calculation, we recommend preparing an invoice-wise statement showing:
- Invoice number and date.
- Delivery or service completion date.
- Acceptance or deemed acceptance date.
- Agreed payment period.
- Applicable due date.
- Original invoice amount.
- Part-payments and their dates.
- Credit notes and adjustments.
- Outstanding principal.
- Applicable statutory interest.
Do not calculate interest by applying one flat rate to the entire claim without checking the relevant dates and RBI-notified bank rates.
A proper calculation should reflect the applicable statutory starting date, rate changes and payment history.
9. How Long Do MSME Conciliation and Arbitration Take?
Section 18(5) of the MSMED Act provides that every reference under Section 18 should be decided within 90 days from the date of making the reference.
However, this statutory provision should not be treated as a guarantee that every matter will finish within 90 calendar days in practice. IndiaCode+1
Actual proceedings may take longer because of:
- Delays in issuing or serving notices.
- Incomplete documentation.
- Buyer objections.
- Requests for additional evidence.
- Adjournments.
- Failed settlement discussions.
- Arbitration pleadings and hearings.
- Case-management and institutional workload.
What is the role of the MSME ODR Scheme?
The Ministry’s Online Dispute Resolution Scheme introduces a voluntary pre-MSEFC stage with:
- Digital Guided Pathway.
- Unmanned Negotiation.
Parties may use either process, both sequentially or opt out of the voluntary pre-MSEFC stage. If the matter remains unresolved, the statutory MSEFC process follows, including conciliation and arbitration. MSME ODR+1
The pre-MSEFC negotiation process is separate from statutory conciliation and should not be mistaken for the arbitration stage.
10. Can a Buyer Challenge an MSEFC Arbitration Award?
Yes. A party may challenge an arbitral award through the legal remedies available under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, subject to the special provisions of the MSMED Act.
Section 19 of the MSMED Act provides an important additional safeguard for suppliers.
Generally, a buyer or other non-supplier appellant seeking to set aside a covered decree, award or order must deposit 75% of the amount in the manner directed by the court before its application can be entertained.
The court may direct payment of a reasonable portion of the deposit to the supplier, subject to applicable conditions.
In M/s Tirupati Steels v. M/s Shubh Industrial Component, the Supreme Court affirmed the mandatory nature of the 75% pre-deposit requirement in a covered challenge, while recognising that instalments may be allowed in appropriate cases to address undue hardship. VoxJuris
The supplier should monitor any challenge and seek advice about enforcement and any stay order.
11. What Happens After an MSME Arbitration Award?
An arbitral award may determine the buyer’s liability, but the supplier still needs to consider whether the buyer will comply voluntarily.
If the buyer does not pay, the supplier may need to pursue enforcement proceedings.
The practical recovery process may involve:
- Obtaining and reviewing the award.
- Checking whether the buyer has challenged it.
- Checking whether any stay or interim order exists.
- Identifying the appropriate court and enforcement procedure.
- Assessing the buyer’s available assets and recovery prospects.
- Taking lawful steps to enforce the award.
An award and actual receipt of money are two different milestones.
A supplier should plan for enforcement rather than assume that the award automatically results in payment.
[Insert Data/Case Study Placeholder: Add an anonymised example of a supplier that obtained an MSEFC award and subsequently pursued enforcement to recover the awarded amount.]
12. MSME Conciliation vs Arbitration vs Enforcement: What Is the Difference?
| Stage | Main purpose | What the supplier seeks | Possible result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Conciliation | Explore an amicable settlement | Agreed payment or settlement terms | Settlement or termination without settlement |
| Arbitration | Obtain a decision on the dispute | A determination of the amount legally due | Arbitral award |
| Award challenge | Review the award through legally available proceedings | Setting aside or defending the award | Court decision |
| Enforcement | Obtain compliance with an enforceable award | Actual payment or recovery | Recovery, subject to available assets and legal process |
This distinction helps MSME owners understand why a payment dispute may continue even after a successful conciliation or arbitration stage.
13. Common Mistakes Businesses Should Avoid During Conciliation and Arbitration
- Filing an incomplete claim without invoice-wise reconciliation.
- Failing to preserve proof of delivery or service completion.
- Ignoring the buyer’s written objections.
- Claiming statutory interest without checking the correct dates and rates.
- Treating a negotiation proposal as a final settlement.
- Missing hearing dates or procedural directions.
- Assuming that the buyer’s absence automatically proves the claim.
- Failing to preserve records of conciliation termination.
- Ignoring limitation and award-enforcement requirements.
- Assuming that receiving an award means the money has already been recovered.
14. How Can Litigation Funding Help During MSME Conciliation, Arbitration and Enforcement?
A business may have a valid delayed-payment claim but lack the financial resources to pursue a lengthy dispute.
The financial pressure can become more serious when the matter moves from conciliation to arbitration or from an award to enforcement.
Depending on the circumstances, a business may need support for:
- Legal representation.
- Arbitration proceedings.
- Document preparation.
- Expert assistance.
- Award enforcement.
- Recovery-related proceedings.
At LegalFund, we are a technology-enabled litigation funding company in India. We evaluate eligible MSME delayed-payment claims, commercial disputes and decree or arbitration award enforcement matters.
Our assessment may consider:
- The supplier’s eligibility.
- The outstanding claim amount.
- Purchase orders and invoices.
- Delivery and acceptance records.
- The buyer’s objections.
- The current conciliation or arbitration stage.
- Any award already passed.
- Whether the award is under challenge.
- Estimated legal and enforcement expenses.
- Potential recovery prospects.
A matter may be considered at different stages, including an ongoing dispute or award-enforcement stage, subject to independent assessment.
Funding is selective and subject to an agreed funding arrangement. It is not automatic, and neither funding nor recovery is guaranteed.
[Insert Data/Case Study Placeholder: Add an anonymised LegalFund case study describing the type of commercial claim evaluated, its procedural stage and the funding assessment.]
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What is the difference between conciliation and arbitration under the MSMED Act?
Conciliation is a settlement-focused process in which a neutral conciliator helps the supplier and buyer explore an agreement. Arbitration is a formal adjudicatory process in which an arbitrator decides the dispute and may issue a binding award.
2. What happens if conciliation fails before the MSEFC?
If statutory conciliation fails and is formally terminated without settlement, Section 18(3) requires the MSEFC to take up the dispute for arbitration or refer it to an appropriate institution or centre for arbitration.
3. How can an MSME recover unpaid invoices through conciliation and arbitration?
An eligible micro or small enterprise can submit a delayed-payment reference, participate in conciliation and, if settlement fails, pursue arbitration. If an award is passed in its favour and the buyer does not comply, the supplier may need to initiate enforcement proceedings.
4. Can a buyer refuse to pay after an MSEFC arbitration award?
The buyer may challenge a covered award through legally available proceedings, but a challenge does not automatically erase the payment liability. Section 19 generally requires a non-supplier appellant to deposit 75% of the awarded amount before a covered challenge can be entertained, subject to the court’s directions.
Explore https://legalfund.in/ to know more